Roads minister says motorists pay for roads

Mike Penning Roads Minister

Of all politicians, you’d think the roads minister would know how roads are funded. Apparently not.

Yesterday in parliament, Mike Penning, the minister in charge of roads and road safety, said:

“We also need to ensure that the motorist, who predominantly pays for our roads, is not inconvenienced too much.”

He was talking in a debate about allowing motor sport to use public highways and ignored a call to allow cycle sport to benefit from the same rule relaxation. He then came out with the corker above.

Should he be in his job if he doesn’t know that roads are paid for out of the consolidated fund and motorists haven’t directly paid a penny for roads since 1937?

Tax-payers – some of whom own cars, some of whom don’t – pay for roads. Roads are paid for out of general and local taxation.

It’s important for ministers to get their facts right on this issue. Why? Because it’s an issue that causes danger for one class of road user: cyclists. Some motorists believe cyclists “don’t pay road tax” and have lesser rights to be on roads. This can lead to animosity towards cyclists, and even violence.

It needs stressing that not one single penny from car tax goes to building or maintaining roads. Vehicle Excise Duty is a tax on vehicles, not a tax to pay for roads. Somebody tell the minister.

Better still, this would be an opportunity for an opposition MP to put Penning on the spot and ask why he said roads are paid for by motorists. Simple mistake or does he really not know? And does he know that such ignorance sometimes spills over into abuse of cyclists?

++++++++++

iPayRoadTax.com is an ironically-named campaign supporting the road rights of cyclists. The message that cyclists have equal rights on the roads is carried on iPayRoadTax t-shirts and jerseys.

  • Anonymous

    What do we expect from these dismal, dissembling morons?

  • Anonymous

    It’s extremely hard not to be rude about such ignorance. If I say any more, I’m afraid I will not be able to control my language.

  • Anonymous

    I must look this guy up later, and then tip off the opposition, then. n;-PnnPeople who come out with comment and ignorance like that are dinosaurs.

  • http://www.quickrelease.tv carltonreid

    To be fair to him, he may just be ignorant.

  • http://www.quickrelease.tv carltonreid

    He likes motor sport, a lot.

  • http://www.quickrelease.tv carltonreid

    MPs say this sort of ignorant guff all the time and I don’t tend to pick holes in them for it. But a minister saying it is a different kettle of coconuts.

  • Pete

    Extraordinary! I was going to post some gratuitous abuse, but thats too easy. These people need our help/to be made unemployed (delete as appropriate)

  • andree-evarts

    he needs to be tied to the bonnet of a fast car in a mud circuit and whipped with bicycle chains by cyclists each time he comes skidding around the bend. a whack for each human killed by the motor car since its invention over 100 years ago. more than world war deaths. the third undeclared world war it has been said!

  • http://www.quickrelease.tv carltonreid

    That’s a very Biblical punishment. I might just stick to the sarcasm. Sorry, I’m a wuss, I know.

  • http://ipayroadtax.com/no-such-thing-as-road-tax/cycle-path-story-in-daily-fail-leads-to-comments-so-hackneyed-theyre-almost-comical/ Cycle path story in Daily Fail leads to comments so hackneyed they’re almost comical – I Pay Road Tax

    [...] Such ignorance of how roads are actually funded (it’s local and national taxation) isn’t confined to ranters on infuriating forums, even the UK Minister for Roads isn’t so sharp on the subject. [...]

  • James Holloway

    Ignorance? Par for the course with this government it seems.

  • Bobynonuts

    The VED goes to the exchequer and some of it will inevitable end up being spent on roads as some will go to the Highways Agency and some to local councils who will use it on local roads. I suspect that it is such as small amount that it makes no difference and that the cyclist probably contributes more in their income tax than the car driver does in their VED. So cyclists have every right if not more right to be on the road because they paid for them.

  • Allterrain

    The whole country is anti cycling. We shouldn’t go through red lights, but we have to stick up ourselves. It’s just a form of bullying